I'd sell my soul for: with Y

• you

  Love, support, and companionship from you 💖

• Yogurt

  Delicious snack or dessert, especially with fruit

• Youth

  Youthful energy, health, and endless possibilities

• youtube

  Endless streaming, memes, and distraction heaven

• your soul

  Classic dark joke wish: power over someone else’s fate

• Yes

  Being told “yes” to everything you ask for forever

• Yummy food

  Endless delicious meals, never‑ending tasty treats

• Yams

  Endless tasty yams—comfort food wish unlocked

• Yen

  Stacks of Japanese yen, money wish for the win

• yoyo

  Magic toy fun forever, never gets boring… probably

The words in the list I'd sell my soul for: with Y come from players of the word game Categories game.